What should a new DD do in month one?

Listen. Meet every board member and top-25 donor, read the last three years of financials and appeals, and don't launch anything new until day 45.

When should the first appeal go out?

Only if the calendar forces it. Otherwise, wait until you've had time to segment the file, refresh the case, and align with the ED — usually month 3 or 4.

How do you handle a broken CRM on day one?

Document what's broken, keep using it, and don't propose a switch in the first 90 days. Migrating too early is the classic new-DD mistake.

What's a fair 90-day evaluation?

Relationships built, systems assessed, and a written 12-month plan. Not dollars raised — that timeline isn't realistic and setting it up that way burns out good hires.

The First 90 Days of a New Development Director

The average nonprofit development director lasts 18 months. The reason is almost never talent. It's the first 90 days — where boards, EDs, and new hires make the same avoidable mistakes over and over.

Weeks 1–4: Listen

Meet every board member, every top-30 donor, every program director, and every development team member. Ask what's working, what's broken, and what they need. Write it down. Fix nothing yet.

Weeks 5–8: Diagnose

Pull retention, average gift, donor pyramid, and pipeline reports. Compare to sector benchmarks. Identify the two things that are most broken and the two easiest wins. Present both to the ED — not the board yet.

Weeks 9–12: Ship

Fix one thing visibly. Land one gift the org didn't expect. Draft the 12-month plan. Present it to the board with clear metrics and one specific ask of them. Now, and only now, are you allowed to start reorganizing.

What to say no to

New event ideas. Rebrands. CRM migrations. Anything that will take 6+ months to show results. In the first 90 days, credibility is currency. Spend it on visible wins.

What the ED should do

Introduce, protect, and hold the line. Introduce the new hire to every relationship that matters. Protect them from unrelated crises. Hold the line when the board or a program director wants their time for something outside the plan.

Frequently asked questions

What should a new DD do in month one?: Listen. Meet every board member and top-25 donor, read the last three years of financials and appeals, and don't launch anything new until day 45.
When should the first appeal go out?: Only if the calendar forces it. Otherwise, wait until you've had time to segment the file, refresh the case, and align with the ED — usually month 3 or 4.
How do you handle a broken CRM on day one?: Document what's broken, keep using it, and don't propose a switch in the first 90 days. Migrating too early is the classic new-DD mistake.
What's a fair 90-day evaluation?: Relationships built, systems assessed, and a written 12-month plan. Not dollars raised — that timeline isn't realistic and setting it up that way burns out good hires.

Need help finding the right consultant?

Browse experienced nonprofit consultants by specialty and state — or let us shortlist a few for you.

Browse consultants Help me find the right one

← Back to ConsultNonprofit.com home Browse all articles →